Pitching Matchup of the Week: New York Yankees vs. Cleveland Indians

July 28, 2010   ·     ·   Jump to comments
Article Source: Bleacher Report - New York Yankees

After splitting the first two games in Cleveland against the Indians, the New York Yankees have shortened their lead in the AL East to just two games over the Tampa Bay Rays.

The Rays are on fire right now. Starting pitcher Matt Garza pitched the franchise’s first no-hitter on Monday night against the Tigers and Tampa followed it up with another win. The Rays have won their last four in a row.

After two more games against a beat-up Tigers team, in come the Yankees. The question is, will the two teams be tied for first place, or can the Yankees win the next two in Cleveland?

For tonight’s game, the Yankees’ fate is at the hands of starter A.J. Burnett, who faces Indians ace Fausto Carmona.

Let’s look at the two hurlers and how they fare against each other on the mound:


Cleveland Indians’ Fausto Carmona

26-year-old Fausto Carmona is the staff ace. He impressed Yankees skipper Joe Girardi so much he named him to the 2010 All-Star roster just a few weeks ago.

In the month of July, Carmona has a 3-1 record with a 2.81 ERA, and he’s given up just eight runs and one home run. He has struck out 17 batters. Carmona’s walk total for the month is 14, which is clearly the right-hander’s weakness.

Two of the three July wins were against the tough Tampa Bay Rays and the other versus the Detroit Tigers. Both opposing teams legitimately feature the best hitters in the league—Miguel Cabrera, Carl Crawford, and Evan Longoria, to just name a few.

Carmona’s 2010 totals, with a 10-7 record and a 3.51 ERA, do not adequately represent how adept he has been. Baseball is a team sport, so when a pitcher gets zero run support due to a weak ballclub, even the best arms will not fare as well. This is a reality for the Indians, and it has impacted Carmona’s individual potential, but not by much.

Carmona will want to attack the zone and stay ahead in pitch counts against a stacked Yankee squad. This is essential because the hottest Yankee bats of Curtis Granderson, Mark Teixeira, Derek Jeter, and Robinson Cano have had success against Carmona in the past. The Yankees hitters are so tolerant that Carmona has to be careful not to walk too many of them.


New York Yankees’ A.J. Burnett

It is no secret that the month of June was not pretty for A.J. Burnett—it was pure horror. The only thing Burnett could do successfully was slamming pies in his teammates faces without any injury.

Since beginning the month of July, Burnett has a 2.61 ERA over 20 2/3 innings. During Burnett’s full 180-degree turn, he has allowed just six hits, one home run, and 13 strikeouts.

It is still a game of Jekyll and Hyde with Burnett on the mound. Burnett’s recently embarrassing conflict with a couple of Yankees’ clubhouse doors might have been the rock bottom behind his surge. This situation ended with Burnett having to apologize to all his teammates, but Captain Derek Jeter made it quite clear that the team views this as a one-time incident.

Burnett has lowered his walk rate tremendously. It is crucial he continue to be dominate tonight, because the team’s position is at stake—second place is the first loser.

Coming off a rare C.C. Sabathia loss, Burnett owes his teammates a quality start, going deep into the game and putting the Yankees in a winning position. The rest is up to the hitters, who have their hands full, so he can not expect too much.


Pitching Prediction

Looking at the bigger picture, I predict the Yankees will beat the Indians, 5-2.

Burnett has to pitch well, while Carmona has to be dominant, because the fact is that the two teams are unfairly matched…big time!


Read more New York Yankees news on BleacherReport.com

readers comments

Yankee Tickets

Yankee Tickets

Shop Yankee

Shop Yankee